Supercapacitors vs. Batteries: A Comparison in Energy Storage Solutions

Posted by Peter Matthews on Sep 18, 2024 8:15:00 AM
Peter Matthews

Supercapacitors feature unique characteristics that set them apart from traditional batteries in energy storage applications. Unlike batteries, which store energy through chemical reactions, supercapacitors store energy electrostatically, enabling rapid charge/discharge cycles. In certain applications, this gives them a significant advantage in terms of power density, lifespan, efficiency, operating temperature range and sustainability.  

Supercapacitors vs. Batteries

In this blog, we’ll explore how supercapacitors compare to conventional battery technologies and examine the key factors driving interest in supercapacitors for modern energy applications. For a high-level specifications overview, see Table 1. 

High Power Density

Supercapacitors store energy electrostatically, so their power density ranges from 10 to 100 times higher than batteries. As a result, they can fully charge in a matter of seconds. Battery chemistry reactions occur at slower speeds, which impacts charge and discharge rates (typically measured in hours). 

Long Life Expectancy

Due to mechanical and chemical degradation, rechargeable batteries wear out after a few thousand charge/discharge cycles maximum. Excluding those with polymer electrodes, supercapacitors have a much longer lifespan than batteries. The lifecycle of electric double layer capacitors (EDLCs) is nearly unlimited because electrostatic energy storage causes less wear and tear on components.

Wide Operating Temperature Range

Supercapacitors can function without significant degradation in environments ranging from −40°C to 70°C. Batteries, particularly lithium-ion batteries, can’t operate across that wide of a temperature range without overheating.

Eco-Friendly

Supercapacitors mostly consist of carbon and its compounds, so they biodegrade, and waste materials are easy to dispose of. Further, packaging is designed to minimize negative environmental impacts.

High Efficiency

In renewable power generation, energy efficiency is paramount. During charging cycles, supercapacitors only experience about 1 percent energy loss, compared to up to 30 percent for lead-acid batteries. 

Parameter  Lead-Acid Battery  Lithium-Ion Battery  Supercapacitor 
Specific energy density (Wh/kg)  10-100 150-200 1-10
Specific power density (Wh/kg)  <1000 <2000 <10,000
Cycle life  1000 5000 >50,000
Charge and discharge efficiency  70-85% 99% 85-98%
Fast charge duration  1-5h 0.5-3h 0.3-30s
Fast discharge duration  0.3-3h 0.3-3h 0.3-30s
Shelf life (years)  5-15 10-20 20
Operating temperature (°C)  -5 to 40 -30 to 60 -40 to 75

Table 1: Comparison of key specification differences between lead-acid batteries, lithium-ion batteries and supercapacitors. Abbreviated from: Source. 

Energy Density vs. Power Density in Energy Storage 

Supercapacitors are best in situations that benefit from short bursts of energy and rapid charge/discharge cycles. They excel in power density, absorbing energy in short bursts, but they have lower energy density compared to batteries (Figure 1). They can’t store as much energy for long-term use. Batteries are more suitable for applications where energy delivery occurs over longer durations. The balance between power density and energy density depends on the application requirements. 

Figure-1-Ragone 

Figure 1: Ragone plot comparing the performance of several common energy storage devices, including supercapacitors and batteries. Source.

Common Supercapacitor Applications 

While supercapacitors are used in many different application areas, they thrive under two key conditions. 

  • High-Power: With their built-in high-power characteristics, supercapacitors are critical in power electronics, where engineers are looking for short-time power peaks.
  • Long Life Cycle: In low-power applications, like security installations, batteries present maintenance issues or insufficient performance over time. Supercapacitors can efficiently handle quick bursts of energy when needed and can endure many more charge/discharge cycles over time. 

Review detailed specifications for our supercapacitor offerings or contact us for an application-specific design consultation. 

For a detailed review on leveraging supercapacitors for efficient wireless power in smart logistics, read our latest white paper. 

Read White Paper

 

Topics: Capacitor

Insights Into Precision Passive Devices

Knowles Precision Devices is a premier global source for Capacitors, RF Filters, EMI Filters, Resonators, non-magnetic components and advanced dielectric materials. An umbrella for the brands of Compex, DLI, Johanson MFG, Novacap, Syfer and Voltronics, Knowles Precision Devices serves a variety of markets including military, aerospace/avionics, medical equipment, implantable devices, EMI and connector filtering, oil exploration, instrumentation, industrial electronics, automotive, telecoms and data networks.

This Blog will provide insights into:

  • Filters for 5G and mmWave
  • Capacitors for High Voltage
  • Capacitors for High Reliability

and much more. Subscribe below to stay informed.

Subscribe Here!

Recent Posts